Thursday August 22, 2019
SNc Channels:



May-06-2010 00:19printcomments

Op Ed: Education Chief Most Effective As Communicator

21st Century Changes Demand Broad New Approaches.

Ron Maurer is the challenger for the state's top educator; held for several years by former TV Reporter Susan Castillo.
Ron Maurer is the challenger for the state's top educator; held for several years by former TV Reporter Susan Castillo.

(EUGENE, Ore.) - On May 18 Oregon must choose its Superintendent of Education. There are two fine candidates this time for the most essential leader charged with directing and further developing the most essential public service we enjoy. One has already “been there, done that”.

The other seeks “make do with less” for a system now becoming notorious for its obvious current short-fall in some few schools. Susan Castillo, the incumbent, comes from the real world of communications, with background beginning with the everyday realities of life at every level, reported reliably and with practical understandings reflected for citizens needing to know for democratic decisions.

Many persons, both within the educational system and generally in our culture, will agree that broad exposure to life-as-lived --and its inherent realistic difficulties-- is more valuable even than the finest of professional preparations in schools of education.

One cannot get better preparation for real life and its inherent difficulties and demanded decisions than by being a news-reporter, sharing those experiences rapidly with strong-minded readers who often respond. (Disclosure: Mine own “checkered career”, mostly by chance, straddles both sides of this reality.) Ron Maurer, albeit prepared for an educational career (Ph.D./N.Ill. U.) spent nine years as an Army officer, administering healthcare in hospital.

He and his wife operated a Rogue River health clinic until this year. On healthcare, he is thus eminently qualified. But he seeks the post of responsibility to prepare Oregon education for all developments that must prevail for the 21st Century. They share legislative experience: Castillo in the Oregon Senate and Maurer in the House.

Maurer is Republican, “small-government, distinctly conservative”, and described as both thoughtful and pragmatic, seeking “to do more with less” funding. Castillo, in a second practical-experience/providing term, facing the destructive impacts of Oregon’s long refusal to build a stable system of state educational funding and the tremendous resulting pressures on every local school district, has intimate knowledge already for what must be done.

She has had two full terms to “learn on-the-job” about the daunting realities every local school board must face these days --sure to continue for at least another term-in-office here. “Learning is best accomplished by Doing” is one strongly-established standard for educational evaluation. Castillo passes that test with flying colors, on the flat fact of past experience and ongoing accomplishment in her current term.

The shaping reality of voter choice here is the inescapable fact that Oregon’s chief educational officer, the Superintendent of Education, does NOT and CANNOT control school policy, finance, OR practices. That remains --as it probably should-- the role and responsibility of the Legislature, the State Board of Education, and the local school districts.

The further/flat-fact is that they must also bear full responsibilities for the outcomes within Oregon’s system. What remains as massive, motivating, shaping and directing power for the Superintendent is the overall supervision of the entire system, to make the most of what the Legislature (and the voters !) DO provide. THAT, friends, is a complex and entirely compelling communications-assignment.

Castillo has spent two full terms in often-painful and always-demanding direct contact with the realities in Oregon’s educational system today. The skills of communication, closely related and most effective in the role of the insightful, sensitive and sensible teacher, is what this office clearly demands.

She needs no newly-begun “learning curve” to teach her what the system now MUST have --if we are ever to have hope for the schools of tomorrow to shape our learners today. “Making do with less”, when our Oregon educational system is already deprived and distressed, will never ever either maintain what we have OR prepare our learners for the already-arrived 21st Century.

What voters can expect from Castillo is even more entirely practical, extremely insightful, and exceptional, detailed development of what more modern educational opportunity may be possible --by whatever means.

Her recent leadership in applying Internet software to assist students in becoming digitally literate, while at the same time saving money for school districts, is an apt demonsration of what’s truly needed NOW. The Google-developed web-based application is furnished free; the savings to districts is estimated at $1.5 million yearly for e-mail, with additional savings for software upgrade no longer needed.

Google has a large data-center operation based in The Dalles. Oregon is the first state to arrange for use of the application statewide.

What this software does is indicative of what’s to come: “This is a way for students to prepare for the workplace by using workplace technology in the classroom,” Department spokesperson Susanne Smith stated. Included are filtered e-mail; online documentation; website creation; streaming media; and other essential applications.

Users can collaborate in real time, using online software and Google for data storage and management. This and other new technological advances are strengthening, extending and multiplying the role of the “virtual classroom” and “virtual school”, right at the time when the classic community-centered institution finds itself facing painful outmoding and further degeneration via lack of rational, reasonable funding. Our whole world is roiling, boiling with massive new demands on every citizen. The fate of our “democratic experiment” depends on what and how we now teach our children.

So our educational system --charged with complex responsibilities to prepare rising generations-- must now reflect those rapid, radical, irresistible new needs and inevitable demands --in every pragmatic aspect of every-teacher planning, practice, performance and full proof-of-learning, for every child in our nation. The best of the past-practices must be skillfully and carefully combined and both strengthened and extended by what the world now offers us. Truly, we can no longer afford to Leave No Child Behind.

BUT we must make sure what we do is strongly positive, providing both the personal rewards of learning accomplishments and the pain of consequential “failures” to be remedied by still-further learning opportunities. THAT, too, is “communication” in most fundamental application, demanding a skilled, practiced, pragmatic communication effort and its communicator.

We must be completely sure the system is now perfected --completely freed of denial, delay and that personal deep-defeat which arises from frustrating the learner. More than two centuries of educational achievement in our nation furnish the foundations for what the world has long seen as the leading demonstration of what our governance system can accomplish. Despite sometimes distressing and sometimes even frustrating results --most often due to lack of truly demanded resources rather than any management failures-- our sysems nationally have done remarkably well for us, as our mutual accomplishments surely prove every day. But this IS the 21st Century NOW !!

What worked ‘back then” and what can now be continued by the best of rational and reasonable further development must now depend on a new level of leadership. That level of achievement hangs heavily on the skills of commuication to provide “the public” with true and tested understandings and appreciations.

At 21, Henry Clay Ruark was Aroostook Editor for the Bangor, Maine DAILY NEWS, covering the upper 1/4 of the state. In the ‘40s, he was Staff Correspondent, then New England Wires Editor at United Press-Boston; later Editor for the Burlington, Vermont 3-daily group owned by Wm. Loeb, later notorious at Manchester, New Hampshire UNION LEADER for attacks on Democratic Presidential candidates.

Hank returned to Oregon to complete M. Ed. degree at OSU, went on to Indiana University for Ed.D. (abd) and special other course-work; was selected as first Information Director for NAVA in Washington, D.C.; helped write sections of NDEA, first Act to supply math, science, foreign language consultants to state depts. of education; joined Oregon Dept. of Education, where he served as NDEA administrator/Learning Media Consultant for ten years.

He joined Dr. Amo DeBernardis at PCC, helping establish, extend programs, facilities, Oregon/national public relations; moved to Chicago as Editor/Publisher of oldest educational-AV journal, reformed as AV GUIDE Magazine; then established and operated Learning Media Associates as general communications consultant group. Due to wife’s illness, he returned to Oregon in 1981, semi-retired, and has continued writing intermittently ever since, joining S-N in 2004. His Op Eds now total over 560 written since then.

Comments Leave a comment on this story.

All comments and messages are approved by people and self promotional links or unacceptable comments are denied.

Hank Ruark May 6, 2010 3:41 pm (Pacific time)

  Re funding, solution depends on interpretation and is being properly pursued via legal system. While in doubt we do better to stick to leader who has had time to learn how to  cope NOW with current crisis.
There's no doubt whatsoever education is deprived and much  damage done thereby.
  Re language/learning needs for newcomers, policy is set by Legislative action, must be followed by OrEdDept.
  IF yr friend so discharged she has legal recourse; did she pursue that ? Doubtful if school district can show any dollar gains so-made.
  Re choice, far better experienced chief who knows territory than any newcomer abandoning private business for political job. IF Maurer sought educational career with PhDEd, where's his proven work in field he prepared for so assiduously over many years ??

  Castillo prepared for her communication career, proved herself by years in public eye winning wide, strong approval,
which was why she was elected to Senate, long known as "the UPPER house" of representative government.

Hank Ruark May 6, 2010 9:17 pm (Pacific time)

D.and B.: ANY new ed/chief named now faces precisely same hampering and harm-making difficulties imposed by lack of Legislative INaction on key points, long and wellknown in state.  Eight years of building the relationships on which ALL educational progress depends-- with school districts,parents, teachers-- is lost if we force change to new man, seeking to replace private-sector gains with precisely what we do NOT need: A demand for "tension with teachers"and "service agency" approach for agency whose only function is TO SERVE !! (Summarized quotes from AP report re Maurer policies-proposed, Register Guard 4/18/10).  Teachers already suffering from district lack of support, added healthcare costs, fewer aides, cuts in books, media, even paper/pencils... You want to force strike situation, destroy what has been built over past eight years, deserves full further support for more childhood education, better high school standards,stronger utilization  of demanded new technologies, more "virtual schools".

To all: Makes NO sense to UN/blame Supt. Castillo, then cut her off just as longtime effort to build strong working relations with districts and teachers, for what parents clearly seek, is showing results of efforts by all-concerned. "Illegals" are result of longtime neocon neglect of our border integrity. UNfunding education is part of same longtime neocon cabal intended to "starve the beast", then blame resulting "failures" due to lack of essential operating strengths on the part of our system so attacked. Cabal now known to have done so ever since Reagan-days, in close support of his fatuous, erroneous "Government IS the problem !" American myth --now seen increasingly by serious cognitive, social, economic scientists as fundamental to many American failings as well as those in education. NCLB by Bush now understood by many as intentional strong emphasis on testing to provide plausible grounds punishing those "failing" the tests. See previous Op Eds here re NCLB, over past four years.

Here's "see with own eyes" evidence of demanded strong relations with teachers, who already face sharpened working situations, now find further personal impacts, too !: Double-Digit Rate Increase Hits Oregon Schools (Lund Report 5/10/2010) By Diane Lund-Muzikant School districts and community colleges face double-digit rate increases for health insurance this fall. The primary reason: high utilization of medical services. Providence Health Plans and The ODS Companies have the steepest increases – 28.5 percent and 18.2 percent respectively, while Kaiser is the lowest cost alternative, with a 9.8 percent hike. None of those rate hikes reflect previous losses by the health plans during the first year of the contract, according to Joan Kapowich, administrator of the Oregon Educators Benefit Board. An earlier article in The Lund Report showed that ODS had suffered losses of $38 million. ----------------------- Please note that only dollar support listed for "new man"(in AP story) comes from big pharm and health industry sources. Might be worth further full exploration or explanation from candidate.

I had ten yrs in OrDeptEd, placing $9 million fed/funds matching district dollars, on changing teaching practices to use new media; that taught me painful solid importance of relationships built on trust and action. That's approach Castillo has already demonstrated as well documented in this Op Ed first in series exploring further developments demanded for 21st Century NOW.  "New man" comes in with own record of opposition and with commitment to push for still more steps most educators see as further hampering and damaging, rather than modernizing and strengthening.

Roger Miles May 6, 2010 6:10 pm (Pacific time)

Douglas B. we are living in a time period when we have people who have come into this country ten or more years ago, legally and illegally, who do not speak english nor are really compelled to do so. As far as who would be the best Supt. Of Education, maybe it's time to trade horses? Things are not going well, and though it may not be the current Supt. entire fault, nonetheless her leadership has not been inspirational enough to get things moving in a positive way. She has had 8 years, that's enough time. We should consider putting time limits on all elected officals, for professional politicians don't seem to work out too well for us. Look at California for evidence in that matter.

Douglas Benson May 6, 2010 8:35 am (Pacific time)

Fist and foremost our legislature needs to follow the law .The voters enacted a law that directs our legislature to FULLY fund education .They have refused and the courts cant force them to do so .I have a very hard time with this ,we are thier bosses .Its a brutal slap in the face to democracy and the voters of Oregon . Second we are robbing our children of valuable learning time and resources with one day english one day spanish garbage . This is wrong on so many levels its not even funny .We will put away the illegal immigrants flooding our schools with children and stealing our resources . What about these children who have only been taught spanish ,now they enter the schools and they still dont learn english ,why should they when we dont force them to . What does that say about the parents ? How do they expect thier children to be upwardly mobile when they dont teach them english . Come on if these children are in middle school and they havent learned english already something is very wrong .I have a family friend [a teacher who is hispanic ]who spoke out publicly about how the system keeps these children illiterate in english to get more monies and they promptly fired her . If we are voting for same old same old I think I will pick the new guy .

[Return to Top]
©2019 All opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of

Articles for May 5, 2010 | Articles for May 6, 2010 | Articles for May 7, 2010


Sean Flynn was a photojournalist in Vietnam, taken captive in 1970 in Cambodia and never seen again.

Donate to and help us keep the news flowing! Thank you.

Annual Hemp Festival & Event Calendar