Thursday August 11, 2022
SNc Channels:



Dec-08-2008 07:29printcomments

Have Irvine and Lennar Ignored Hazardous Nuclear Waste at El Toro?

The Chair for the former Marine base Technical Subcommittee in 2000, went public with details about nuclear contamination at El Toro shortly before his death the same year.

old El Toro MCAS gas station
A view toward the foundation of the old El Toro gas station
Photo by Tim King

(IRVINE, Calif.) - We have written several articles and produced a number of video reports about the environmental damage on the grounds of the now-closed El Toro Marine Corps Air Station in Orange County, California. Most of the stories revolved around contamination from TCE, trichloroethelyne, an aircraft degreaser sold to the U.S. government by Dow Chemical.

As it turns out, the deadly cancer-causing and liver killing TCE may just be the tip of the iceberg. El Toro is also contaminated by nuclear waste.

One problem with El Toro, is that most of the people involved in the decisions to subject Marines and their families and civilian workers to hazardous conditions, are dead. A former Marine, Robert O'Dowd, who also writes for, says that the doctor who wrote the most comprehensive article written about the problems with radioactive waste at this old Marine base, died of a heart attack the same year he wrote it.

Dead men tell no tales, but those who publish their research go on helping people long after they are gone. That is the case with the late Dr. Chuck Bennett, former Chair of the Technical Subcommittee, on the Restoration Advisory Board for the Former MCAS at El Toro.

A letter he wrote May 29th 2000 for the Fullerton Observer, was titled "An Update on Critical Issues for the El Toro Base Closure". Sadly, the doctor did not live long enough to press his cause. The City of Irvine, The Irvine Ranch Water District, and the "Great Parks" Corporation certainly don't want it to be an active topic, and now we discover that it is also a radioactive topic. Along with the disputed contractor Lennar, the agencies planned to turn El Toro into a park and housing community. It is totally amazing that the people of California ever allowed it to go so far.

I learned this summer that the toxic waste is at surface level in the area where I was stationed as a Marine at this base in the early 1980's. After parking for approximately ten minutes last July, I drove away from the hangar and noticed a distinct thumping sound. I got out and looked at my left front tire, and saw that asphalt or blacktop, had clung to my tire in a big glob. TCE is a chemical solvent. The old base is extremely toxic. If you stand near the old MWSG-37 area, you are standing right on top of it. This is the area that Irvine wants to see become a park for children.

The gigantic home building contractor Lennar's plunging stock values will not improve as a result of this deal. The bottom has seriously dropped out of the housing market in Southern California, and TCE and nuclear contamination just don't give a place great appeal.

Dr. Bennett wrote, "Five decades of military operation have certainly had its impact on the environment at El Toro. Over 400 underground storage tanks that do not meet the 1998 Federal guidelines for storage use must be taken care of, which means either removed or closed in place."

"It will take years to clean up or take care of the messes that the DoN sprinkled over 4500 acres of prime Orange County land. It may be prime land, but it sure isn’t pristine land! The DoN has made it clear that they have no intention of returning pristine land to the County. They will clean up the 4500 acres only to the levels that the Regulatory Agencies require."

A number of topics are discussed in Dr. Bennett's letter. One regards "an important report" from Department of Navy Consultants released in 2000, about radionuclides in the groundwater at El Toro near the four landfills and also in "Site 1", the EOD, or Explosives Ordnance Disposal area.

Consultants concluded at the time, that the only radionuclide of importance present at the site, was Uranium of natural origin. Dr. Bennett said that if it is of natural origin the DoN would have no obligation to remediate the Uranium.

"But the DoN has a bit of a problem," Dr. Bennett wrote.

"The Uranium they found in Site 1 has too much Uranium 235 in it (N.B. it is the U235 in Uranium that makes nuclear power plants work and splits when an atom bomb explodes). The amount of U235 in the Site 1 samples is more than twice as much as you would find in natural uranium, and several outside experts have confirmed that the Site 1 results demonstrate enriched uranium. If it is enriched, it is man made and not natural. If it is not natural, the DoN will become liable for remediating all the Uranium. If it is shown to be enriched Uranium at the base, don’t bother to ask me how it got there. Ask the DoN."

He also cited DoN records that he says show that one of the landfills (IRP Site 2) had a different, and larger, defined boundary as late as 1997. What the doctor described as a dangling "Tail" of this old landfill boundary, went outside the boundary of the base. The DoN reports also found buried waste in this "Tail".

"The main problem is that the County is planning to build a road extension right on top of this 'Tail' which may contain DoN waste," Dr. Bennett wrote. I'm not positive, but I was at El Toro this summer for a series of video reports on this subject, and I think that the road mentioned in the letter, now exists.

Nukes at El Toro?

So if nuclear waste exists at El Toro, how did it get there? A former El Toro Marine who chose not to be named in this report, served there in the 1950's. He explained:

"The first use of a small nuclear weapons (small enough to be on the hard points under a Sky Hawk) was done by the Navy and quite possibly, Marine aviators in the 50’s."

The A-4 Sky Hawk was one of the Marine Corps' primary attack jets until they were replaced in the early 1980's by the F/A-18 Hornet.

The former Marine said, "our squadrons worked out of El Toro and the test or (tests) were actually carried out on the Yucca Flats (or wherever we did the bulk of our ground testing which included even smaller nuclear weapons which could be mounted on 105-155 etc artillery)."

I am hoping to hear from Marines and former Marines and anyone else who may have information regarding the nuclear contamination at El Toro. We have been following the TCE contamination issue very closely, and want to make contact with Marines, former Marines, family members and civilian employees from El Toro regarding that. We have a growing list of names and email addresses and we will share critical information as it comes our way.

Also, my wife and I were at El Toro when protests outside the back gate were regular fare. The groups were protesting nuclear weapons that were being stored at El Toro at that time. We will be gathering the details on that period also.

In an extremely important development, there is a petition seeking signatures on behalf of El Toro Marines. That is being circulated by Robert O'Dowd, former El Toro Marine and writer for Petition for Marine Veterans at Risk

Robert O'Dowd operates the Website, It contains a substantial amount of information on his findings regarding El Toro. (Robert and I both served in Marine Wing Support Group 37, now called "Ground Zero" at El Toro as it is the most contaminated part of the base.)

Here is a complete list of the articles that have been generated on the contamination of the former Marine Base at El Toro:

Marine Veterans Lead Petition Drive - Robert J. O'Dowd for

'A Few Good Men, Lots of Chemicals' - Robert J. O'Dowd for

Orange County Turns Blind Eye to Toxicity of Former Marine Base - Tim King

El Toro's Wells Still Suspect- Robert J. O'Dowd for

Marines Unaware of Risks- Robert J. O'Dowd for

TCE Expert Talks With Former El Toro Marine About Toxic Waste (VIDEO) - Tim King

Contaminated Marine Base in Irvine Slated for Public Park and Community Development (VIDEO REPORT) - Tim King

Memories of the El Toro Marine Air Base: a Modern Day Ghost Town - Tim King

Deadly Toxic Chemicals From Marine Base Threaten Irvine Neighborhoods (VIDEO REPORT) - Tim King

Irvine, California Threatened by Contaminated Water From El Toro Marine Base (VIDEO REPORT)- Tim King

El Toro Contamination Reports will Continue - Tim King

Sick Marines and Contaminated Water: Questions Surround El Toro Marine Air Base (VIDEO REPORT)- Tim King

Watch for our Series on El Toro Marine Base Contamination - Tim King

In-Depth Look at El Toro Marine Base TCE Contamination Begins Next Week - Tim King

Tim King is a former U.S. Marine with twenty years of experience on the west coast as a television news producer, photojournalist, reporter and assignment editor. In addition to his role as a war correspondent, this Los Angeles native serves as's Executive News Editor.
Tim spent the winter of 2006/07 in Afghanistan with Oregon troops. Tim recently returned from Iraq where he covered the war there while embedded with an Oregon Guard aviation unit. Serving the community in very real terms, is the nation's only truly independent high traffic news Website, affiliated with Google News and several other major search engines and news aggregators.
You can send Tim an email at this address:

Comments Leave a comment on this story.

All comments and messages are approved by people and self promotional links or unacceptable comments are denied.

BOB December 9, 2008 6:53 am (Pacific time)

Not to worry Larry Agran and his buddies will give the base a "GLOWING" Bill-of-Health" and proceed to circumvent all City of Irvine regulations and move forward with his own agenda and bring Orange County a Great Park everyone can look at and be proud... Just don't dare to stand on it!

[Return to Top]
©2022 All opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of

Articles for December 7, 2008 | Articles for December 8, 2008 | Articles for December 9, 2008
Tribute to Palestine and to the incredible courage, determination and struggle of the Palestinian People. ~Dom Martin

The NAACP of the Willamette Valley


Annual Hemp Festival & Event Calendar